Marketing Information

Case Study: How to Get a Big Boost in Response by Taking Your Marketing to the Extreme


Want a big boost in response and quick sales from your next direct marketing effort? Then take your marketing to the extreme. What do I mean by extreme? I mean unconventional, break the mold, out-of-the-box, reaches-out-and-grabs-people-by-the-lapel marketing.

When you take your marketing to the extreme a lot of people will love it and a few will hate it. But hardly anyone will be able to totally ignore it. With a well thought out, well executed extreme marketing program your presence WILL be known, and in short order you WILL be rewarded.

Extreme marketing to the collision repair industry: A case study
Last year Positive Response helped a leading vendor to the collision repair industry put together an extreme marketing program targeting collision repair shops nationwide. What I'm going to do now is share with you the pertinent details of this campaign. Then I'll give you a few specific ideas about how you can use a similar approach to generate leads and sales for your business, plus a few other direct marketing nuggets.

My client, CSi Complete, (www.csicomplete.com) is the leading provider of phone-based customer satisfaction indexing services to the collision repair industry. After getting their attention -- and a meeting -- with my own extreme marketing efforts they engaged Positive Response to help them put together a program for them. John Webb, the company's vice president of marketing said, "It worked on me. So I figured it might work on somebody else."

What we decided on was a three-step campaign aimed at 300 collision repair businesses throughout the United States.

Step one: Message In a Bottle
CSi Complete's first mailer was a Message In a Bottle -- a 32-ounce squeeze water bottle like the type you might take to the gym. The outside of the bottle was printed with an eye-catching graphic along with their logo and complete contact information. Inside the bottle, which also served as the envelope, was a letter.

The headline on the letter read, "Thirsty for more repair orders? Get ready to drink up!" Body copy talked about the many benefits of using the firm's CSI services. More importantly, the letter offered readers a free gift for talking with the company's Director of Sales, and 13 months of service for the price of 12 if they signed up for CSi's service by a specific date. As 2004 was a leap year we called this our special leap year promotion.

Step two: Bank bag mailing
Approximately a week later CSi sent out a second mailer. Mailer two was a 5.5" x 10.5" bank pouch imprinted with the words, "PUT MORE MONEY IN THE BANK." It arrived in a 9-by-12-inch full-window envelope with the imprinted side of the pouch facing the window. (Another attention-grabbing way of mailing this item is to mail it without using an envelope. To do this you simply tape down the zipper-pull and affix a mailing label and postage to the blank side.)

Inside the pouch was a letter. This time the headline read, "How to write more repair orders while lowering your overhead and improving workplace performance. And you can take that to the bank!"

This letter highlighted three ways CSi Complete helps collision repair shops bank more profits and reiterated our two-pronged offer.

Step three: Trash can mailing
After each mailing CSi's telemarketing staff made follow-up phone calls to book tele-meetings with the company's Director of Sales, Erich Keller. After two mailings and two phone calls a number of people had either booked a tele-meeting or indicated they were not a serious prospect for CSi's service. The remaining group, 208 companies in all, was sent a third and final mailing: a miniature trash can mailed in a box.

Inside the trash can was a wadded up letter with the headline, "Can do? Yes! CSi Complete CAN help you run a more profitable business." An overline -- copy positioned after the name and address but before the salutation -- read in part, "In case you've been throwing my letters into the trash, I wanted to do it for you this time." Body copy in this letter punched up the key selling points made in previous letters and once again highlighted the two-pronged offer.

So, how successful was this program? Very. It generated a healthy number of new accounts in a relatively short period of time. All totaled, the company's Director of Sales conducted 42 tele-meetings (a 14% response) and within three months of completing the campaign CSi Complete had closed nine new pieces of business. Within five months of completion the number of new accounts attributed to the campaign and promotional products had grown to fifteen.

Good advice from Thomas Edison
The great inventor Thomas Edison said, "Keep on the lookout for novel ideas that others have used successfully." That's good advice, not only for inventors but for marketers too. For example, CSi Complete's "novel ideas" can easily be used by owners and marketers of collision repair shops as well as other businesses.

Obviously a collision repair shop wouldn't use this approach for marketing to consumers. But for those businesses with the potential to do or refer a large volume of business an extreme marketing program makes sense.

For example, here's how the very same companies CSi Complete was targeting, collision repair shops, might effectively adapt CSi Complete's extreme marketing program to target corporate fleet managers and referring insurance agents.

Message in a bottle (Fleet managers) - Sample letter headline: "Q: How do you satisfy your thirst for top-notch collision repair AND unsurpassed customer service? A: You send your fleet's autobody repair work to ___________________."

Message in a bottle (Referring agents) - Sample letter headline: "Q: How do you satisfy your clients' thirst for top-notch collision repair AND unsurpassed customer service? A: You send them to ___________________."

Bank bag mailing (Fleet managers) - Sample letter headline: "You know what your company wants from a collision repair shop: Top-quality work AND superb customer service. You'll get both when you work with ___________________. And you can take that to the bank!"

Bank bag mailing (Referring agents) - Sample letter headline: "You know your clients. And you know what they want from a collision repair shop: Top-quality work AND superb customer service. They'll get both when you send them to ___________________. collision repair. And you can take that to the bank!"

Trash can mailer (Fleet managers) - Sample letter headline: "Can do? Yes! (Name of fleet manager's company) and _________________ can build a strong working relationship that benefits everyone." Sub-head: "In case you've been throwing my letters in the trash I wanted to do it for you this time. But before you trash this, my final letter, consider?"

Trash can mailer (Referring agents) - Sample letter headline: "Can do? Yes! (Name of Agent) and _______________ can build a strong working relationship that benefits everyone." Sub-head: "In case you've been throwing my letters in the trash I wanted to do it for you this time. But before you trash this, my final letter, consider?"

This is just one example of how a collision repair shop might adapt CSi Complete's successful program to achieve their marketing and sales objectives. As for other ideas and products, you are limited only by imagination -- yours and that of others whose ideas you can adapt. For example, a different spin on the message in a bottle might be to send it out in a plastic baby bottle. Yes, you read that right. I said BABY BOTTLE.

Sample copy: "Remember the really good old days?When the world really did revolve around you? When your every want and need was tended to? Well those good old days still exist - at _________________." Alternative: "For craftsmanship and service so good you'll see why our competitors are always crying about us stealing business from them - send your fleet's autobody repairs to ______________."

As for a different spin on the bank bag mailing, send your letter out in a translucent blue plastic piggy bank shaped like a bowling pin. Throw a couple of pennies into the bank.

Sample copy: "Mediocre craftsmanship and unresponsive service got you feeling blue about your company's autobody repair shop? For top-notch work and unsurpassed service that will bowl you over send your fleet's autobody repairs ___________________. Give me a call today and let's strike a deal. And I promise, we'll NEVER treat your business like small change."

Then again, you may want to take an entirely different approach with your extreme marketing campaign. As I wrote, you're limited only by your imagination. Not in the collision repair business? Again, use your imagination. The bottle, bank bag, trashcan campaign can easily be tweaked to suit just about any business.

Key factors will impact your success
It's been said that the typical executive gets 175 pieces of mail a week so making your mail stand out is crucial to your success. After all, "attention" is the first step in both the sales and advertising process. But direct marketing is a three-legged stool and in order to maximize your success you'll want to make sure all three legs of your stool are strong and sturdy. Those three legs are -

1. List - Make absolutely sure you're sending your mail to the right people at the right companies. Your list can account for up to 40% of your success.

2. Offer - Make sure you have an offer that gives the prospect a reason to talk with you or meet with you. And the offer isn't what a great job your shop is going to do for them or their clients. Your offer is the stimulus for action. It's the "deal." The quid pro quo. "I'll give you a free video, a special premium, a chance to win?if you'll?."

The use of a premium, the proverbial "free gift," has historically proven to be a very strong offer, pulling four times as many responses as typically is the case without a premium offer. And this is important. Because your offer can account for up to another 40% of your success.

3. Copy - If you invest good money using memorable, attention grabbing mailers in your extreme marketing campaign?but give short shrift to the messaging that goes with it, then all you have working for you is a GIMMICK. And a GIMMICK will only take you so far.

My advice is always this: Unless you would hire yourself (or your staff member) out for pay as a professional direct response copywriter please DON'T write your own copy. The additional response you'll gain by using the services of a skilled, experienced professional will be well worth the investment. Especially when you consider that your copy accounts for up to 20% of your success.

Love and hate (but mostly love)
As I wrote at the beginning of this article, when you take your marketing to the extreme a lot of people will love it and a few will hate it. But hardly anyone will be able to totally ignore it.

For example, in a recent effort of my own I had two diametrically opposite phone calls in the same day. One call was from a somewhat irritated man who wanted his company removed from my mailing list. No problem I said. A couple of hours later I had another call from a gentleman with a big smile in his voice chuckling to me about "the really cool mailers you've been sending me." He scheduled a meeting with me.

Research has shown that well done extreme marketing much more often elicits the latter response than it does the former. In fact, in one extensive test program the response rate for an extreme marketing effort was 74% better than for that of a more conventional effort. To which I say, go forth and do likewise.

Copyright 2005 by Ernest W. Nicastro

Ernest Nicastro, a sales and marketing Pro for more than 25 years, heads up Positive Response, a marketing consulting, advertising and promotions firm. For a FREE copy of the Positive Response Special Report, 77 Sure-Fire Marketing Tips Guaranteed To Boost Results send an email (subject line Tips to ENicastro@positiveresponse.com. For more information on how Positive Response can help your business grow call 614-747-2256 or go tohttp://www.positiveresponse.com.


MORE RESOURCES:
Business:Marketing Articles from EzineArticles.com
07/08/2019 12:46 PM
Won't Turn Pink In The Can
There's an apocryphal story about a tuna cannery at the turn of the 20th century. How do you position tuna against the much more popular canned salmon? You tell the truth, and create a position statement.
06/06/2019 03:08 PM
4 Reasons Why Digital Marketing Is Important for Small Businesses
83% of SMBs (small businesses) believe digital marketing (DM) is crucial for their businesses. Can you beat that? A simple "No".
06/06/2019 03:00 PM
Where Refrigerators Go to Die
We are constantly told if we don't keep up with technology our businesses will fall behind. Where early innovators are quick to embrace the latest labor-saving equipment or software, others still trail the field, hanging on to the last breath until they themselves run the risk of becoming obsolete.
06/04/2019 10:54 AM
Impact of Shift to Polymeric Cables on DC and AC Cable Accessories
In the arena of power transmission, there has been a continual shift from paper cable technology to polymeric-insulated cable technology. However, technicians are still not very certain when it comes to making a right choice between the two of them for their application.
06/04/2019 09:41 AM
Nine Ways to Make Your Business Visible
Imagine that you woke up one morning and discovered you were completely invisible. And nobody could hear you either. If you sent an email, nobody would even see it.
06/04/2019 09:38 AM
Marketing With Logic and Emotion
A couple days ago our refrigerator conked out. A repairman showed up today to take a look. The verdict?
06/04/2019 09:36 AM
What a Sasquatch Can Teach You About Attracting Clients
"Nobody likes sleeping on a plastic bag! Other protectors turn your bed crinkly or stiff and they make your mattress noisy, hot and uncomfortable - like a Nickleback concert - or the first year of my marriage!
05/30/2019 10:37 AM
Law 1 - YOU Are the Killer App
This article is the second in an eight-article series on the Seven Laws of Marketing. See the first article at this link.
05/29/2019 05:25 PM
Myths and Truths About Marketing to Millennials
When it comes to marketing tactics and what supposedly works and what doesn't, it can be hard to cut through the myths to get to the facts. If you're trying to market to millennials, here are some important truths you need to keep in mind when creating your campaigns.
05/28/2019 09:22 AM
The 7 Laws of Attracting Your Ideal Clients
A good story has three parts: 1. The original situation of the client, 2. What you did to help them, 3. The results the client realized from working with you.
05/27/2019 04:02 PM
Money - Increase Your Sales by Adding Bonuses
In a practice known as the "baker's dozen" a baker throws in an extra muffin or cinnamon roll when you buy 12. We all love to receive some kind of bonus when we buy a product. But we tend to underestimate how powerful this tool can be to increasing sales.
05/24/2019 12:45 PM
Money - Discovering Your True Value
Today's article is the second in a multi-part series on making more money in your business. The main reason I'm writing this series on making more money is that, in my experience, most independent professionals are simply undercharging for their services. Last week I talked about how limiting beliefs about money may be holding you back.
05/24/2019 12:44 PM
Money - And How to Make More of It
I don't know many independent professionals who wouldn't like to make more money. It seems so simple. Ultimately there are only four ways to make more money in your business: 1.
05/23/2019 01:57 PM
What's the Hardest Part of Marketing Yourself?
Your prospects are not looking for perfection from you; they're looking for assistance and value. If you've got that, perfection is virtually irrelevant.
05/23/2019 01:56 PM
Website Insights for a Site That Attracts More Clients
Virtually all my business over the past 20 years has come from email promotions to those who joined the list on my website. When you don't have a list, you severely limit your marketing possibilities.
05/20/2019 10:45 AM
Directory Websites Listings On Google Need Cleaning Up Big Time
As a start-up consultant I often find myself putting in a little extra effort when it comes to getting the ball rolling. Why, you ask? It's simple, start-ups only succeed when everyone gives 110% and sometimes even that isn't enough. Anyway, let me tell you of a rather enlightening experience I recently had when helping a new company with their grass-roots marketing campaign. First we sat the team down and explained how we were going to do some cold-calling; phone, person-to-person meetings. Really getting out there and going for it, leaving no stone unturned.
05/17/2019 03:19 PM
Fighting Truthiness and Hype in Marketing
In 2005, Stephen Colbert, in his TV show, the Colbert Report, coined the word, "truthiness." Truthiness is the belief or assertion that a particular statement is true based on the intuition or perceptions of some individual or individuals, without regard to evidence, logic, intellectual examination, or facts. Truthiness can range from ignorant assertions of falsehoods to deliberate duplicity or propaganda intended to sway opinions.
05/17/2019 03:13 PM
How to Use Follow-Up to Renew Old Clients
Instead, you want to get into present time and find out about them. And this is definitely the most important part of the call.
05/16/2019 12:00 PM
14 Ways to Improve Your Email Marketing
Email marketing is a cost effective way for small business to get their message across to prospective customers. Whether you are trying to increase click through rates (CTR) to your website or ecommerce store, increase your email open rates or boost the number of times an email is shared, there are some things to keep in mind to help you improve your approach. It's a good way to engage with past, present and future customers.
05/16/2019 11:59 AM
How to Find Your Marketing Sweet Spot
Ever feel you're making a lot of forward progress but don't really know where you're going? Today a client brought this up in an email to me. She's been doing great at attracting new clients but wants to get a different kind of client and is not sure of her direction.
05/16/2019 11:55 AM
Why Nobody Is Reading Your Marketing Content
Almost every week I'm telling a client that there's a big problem with their marketing content. It's not the subject matter, their writing style, their grammar, or even typos. The problem is that their content is simply hard to read because of the way it's formatted.
05/14/2019 03:42 PM
10 Obsessive Ways You're Undermining Your Business
Roger is an independent professional creative, much like you and me. He does his own specialized version of consulting, coaching, and training. Roger is great at what he does and has had many successes, but he often feels unfulfilled and dissatisfied with the progress of his business and marketing.
05/13/2019 01:45 PM
How to Make Your Outreach Campaign Work
I was speaking to a client last week about her marketing plan. She had developed a somewhat complicated plan to get the attention of her prospective clients. It had to do with networking within an organization, getting attention and credibility and then setting up appointments with those she met.
05/09/2019 03:27 PM
Marketing A Business - How To Market A Business On A Small Budget
Starting a business takes a huge amount of cash. The more you can save, the better. Here are some alternatives to help you create some buzz for your business on a budget.
05/09/2019 03:27 PM
The No Joke System for Attracting Clients
A few months ago I re-tooled my system for teaching people to attract new clients. It's a new take on an old approach. I called it ABDO - Attention-Based Direct Outreach.
05/09/2019 09:17 AM
The Long Lost Art of Being Discovered
One of the most of fascinating Hollywood legends is the discovery of film actress Lana Turner at the soda fountain in Schwab's drug store in Hollywood, by director Mervyn Le Roy in 1936. Wikipedia tells a different story, saying that Turner was discovered by The Hollywood Reporter publisher, William Wilkerson, not at Schwab's, but at the Top Hat Caf?. Nevertheless, this legendary story gave rise to the American myth that "anybody can be discovered, anyone can be successful because of a stroke of luck and the right connections.
05/07/2019 02:10 PM
For GOD's Sake, Just Try Something New!
I really admire successful people. And over the years, I've studied many of them, read their biographies and books and tried to emulate their strategies. These books have helped me, but it wasn't their strategies that gave me the most valuable insights.
05/07/2019 01:10 PM
Is Your Business a "Service" or a "Brand"?
New cell phones were no longer compared to wired phones, but to other cell phones. And what was emphasized were all the new features of that cell phone.
05/07/2019 10:59 AM
Working Your Business From the Zone of Genius
In my experience, there are several more than four. The following are the ones I'm most familiar with, for myself and with client's I've worked with.
05/06/2019 02:57 PM
The Amazing Power of Accountability
I found myself saying to Keith, "OK, I'll go to the gym 3 times a week, starting on Friday. And since that time, almost three weeks ago, I've gone eight times. I do a one-hour circuit using the gym's weight machines.
05/06/2019 02:52 PM
A Guarantee: The Most Powerful Brand for Your Business
I'm currently working with a client right now who does high-end sales training. And we're currently working on the messaging for his website. In the course of our conversations he mentioned that 82% of his clients got a 10:1 ROI on their training investment.
04/30/2019 04:09 PM
The Genius Formula: Plan, Promise, Schedule
The good news is that research has shown exactly what it does take to establish a new positive habit. And it's so simple that most people have missed or disregarded it.
04/30/2019 04:08 PM
Stop an Addictive Habit - And Replace It With an Inspiring One
If James Clear, doesn't float your boat, just use the search function on Medium to find articles on any topic under the sun. Just avoid the political ones! (However, even on that topic, you'll find more interesting, thought-provoking articles than on most news sites.)
04/30/2019 03:59 PM
The Hardest Thing About Being Self-Employed
I rarely travel anywhere for business and meet all my clients by phone or video conference. And email is my preferred communication medium. A perfect set-up for an introvert like me.
04/30/2019 03:57 PM
ChatBot Marketing With Aritificial Intelligence
ChatBot Digital Marketing which makes use of Artificial Intelligence technologies can be used a key component in any company's marketing strategy in terms of guiding customers through a marketing sales funnel. The marketing funnel that would be programmed into the AI ChatBot would be defined in relation to the products and services being offered into the market place from the company in question. Implementation of the particular social media digital marketing strategy may well be devised by a full service digital marketing agency.
04/30/2019 03:55 PM
Why Most Online Marketing Is a Waste of Time - What Works Instead
These days, when it comes to growing your business, all you hear about is online marketing. And it's what everyone would like to use to attract more of their ideal clients. After all, if more prospective clients simply found your website online, you'd get more business, right?
04/26/2019 09:15 AM
How to Get More Email Response
One of the most successful participants was a career coach who worked with doctors and had also been a practicing doctor herself. She contacted past colleagues by email and phone and was successful in doubling her practice in about three months.
04/24/2019 12:04 PM
3 Steps to Influence Your Personal Brand & Become a Thought Leader
Thought leadership is not just about being known - it's being known to make a difference. Here are 3 steps you can take to gain credibility, influence your industry, and be recognized as a thought leader.
04/24/2019 11:55 AM
How to Successfully Meet the Three Biggest Marketing Challenges
One way to zero in on the value of your service is to define the top three attributes your service possesses. One or two is not enough; five or six tends to dilute your message.
04/24/2019 11:53 AM
How to Select the Right Marketing Strategy for Your Business
I've probably had more conversations about this topic with clients than any other: What marketing strategies should I use to market my professional services? These days, there are more options to market yourself than ever before. And you may have a tendency to look for something quick and easy that will generate a never-ending stream of new prospective clients.
04/24/2019 11:51 AM
Nail Your Marketing Message in Your LinkedIn Profile
First of all, the Summary has limitations. You can't use bold or colored or large size type. But you can use all caps for the headings for each paragraph that makes your summary sections pop out, increasing readability.
04/24/2019 11:50 AM
How to Turn Intangible Concepts Into Tangible Services
You accomplish this is by "writing a service or program into existence." This pure act of creation transforms the intangible into the tangible. And now you really have something to sell.
04/24/2019 11:48 AM
A Different Approach to Goal Setting
We all know that it's important to set goals. Unfortunately, the way we think about goals tends to reduce the chance that we'll achieve them or that they'll fulfill us. This is the first of five articles about the 5 Pillars of Marketing, my marketing model that helps get your marketing on track.
04/24/2019 11:47 AM
The Five Pillars of Marketing Success
Does the following give a pretty good picture of your current marketing activity? You have a website but you're not really satisfied with it. You go to networking events once in awhile.
04/24/2019 11:44 AM
Habits - The Big Secret to Marketing Success
Action Plan Marketing helps self-employed people attract more clients through action-oriented marketing strategies that get you in front of prospective clients. Get our free report on how you can attract more of your ideal clients at this link: http://actionplan.club/free-stuff.
04/24/2019 11:42 AM
Fearlessness Is About Being, Not Doing23
It's the recognition that being without fear is essential to who we are. It's as normal and as natural as breathing. It's how we were all born. And we can literally come back to fearlessness with every breath. Look, right now you are aware. You are also here and now in this moment.
04/24/2019 11:37 AM
The Fearless Landing
Yes, it may take some time to do these things well and effectively, but they are not inherently fear-inducing. They are things you can learn to do and ultimately apply to attract new clients to your business.
04/23/2019 03:25 PM
Why Is Writing Funny So Hard?
However, if you are determined to maintain your staid, cool demeanor, be my guest. But I'm afraid your emails won't be getting a lot of attention.
04/23/2019 03:25 PM
Marketing Writing: From My Dog's Perspective
1. I've been writing in my business for 35 years. And pretty much regularly, once a week for 22 years. 2. I own two very adorable, wonderful dogs, Dylan and Meera.
04/23/2019 02:41 PM
Marketing Theory Without Execution: An Idea With No Follow-Through
An ongoing debate exists in the marketing industry that begs the following question: Is it more important to devise a marketing strategy or to execute actions to achieve your goal? There are good arguments all the way around this debate, but when it comes down to it, the answer is really... neither. You simply can't be successful without either one.


home | site map |